Building the wrong product is one of the most sobering realizations a leader can face. It feels like standing in the middle of a house you’ve just finished – the walls are solid, the wiring is perfect, and the paint is fresh; only to realize it’s built on the wrong piece of land.
That realization is heavy, but it happens to even the best product leaders.
How Did We End Up Here?
Building the “wrong” product usually isn’t about incompetence; it’s born from reasonable assumptions that didn’t age well. You might have:
1. Mistaken 1–2 loud customers for the entire market.
2. Inherited a direction you didn’t have the chance to shape.
3. Watched the market evolve faster than your roadmap could keep up.
4. Optimized for features while the customer was actually optimizing for a specific outcome.
I once worked on a workflow tool where we built deep customization because two enterprise clients demanded it. We built a “Swiss Army knife” when the broader market actually just wanted a simple “butter knife”. It was technically impressive, but commercially misaligned.
The Hardest Step: Stop
When you realize you’re off-course, the instinct is to “fix” it by building more – adding a feature or doubling down on marketing. But that’s like realizing you took a wrong turn on the highway and pressing the accelerator.
Speed doesn’t fix direction.
The most courageous move is to Stop. Pause development and tell engineering: “We are not building until we know exactly what we’re building toward”. This causes panic. Engineers will ask if they’re falling behind; leadership will ask why you’re slowing down.
The answer is simple: Clarity beats velocity. So we have to go back to the basics.
When you pause, you have to go back to the foundational basics:
1. Who are we actually serving?
2. What job are they hiring us to do?
3. What has actually worked so far?
I once paused an entire roadmap for three months when adoption flatlined. Instead of shipping, we shadowed users and analyzed churn. We discovered that the market had moved toward automation while we were still optimizing for control. We only found that out because we stopped building.
The corporate instinct is to keep moving because stillness feels like failure. But discovery isn’t “idle time”—it’s a strategic investment. In this phase, your KPI isn’t velocity; it’s your learning rate.
The Unique Angle: “Wrong” is Information.
Building the wrong product isn’t a failure; it’s data. It tells you your assumptions were incomplete or your customer sample was too narrow.
The only real failure is refusing to admit it. Sometimes, the bravest thing a leader can say is: “We’re stopping—until we know we’re right.”
Join the PM Community 